KingPepe2010 (talk | contribs) (About the list) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Personally, I think the list should stay as it documents all the Denjuu/Pokemon found within the game. It's obvious that Waixing was not faithful to the original source material and did not port all (to my knowledge) the proper Denjuu in (and threw a bunch of Pokemon into the mix) as well as renaming all of them. If this was say, making a list of all the Pokemon from Lei Dian Huang Bi Ka Qiu Chuan Shuo, that would be rather pointless as all of the Pokemon are in plus a few additions into the trivia. [[User:KingPepe2010|KingPepe2010]] ([[User talk:KingPepe2010|talk]]) 19:19, July 18, 2018 (UTC) |
Personally, I think the list should stay as it documents all the Denjuu/Pokemon found within the game. It's obvious that Waixing was not faithful to the original source material and did not port all (to my knowledge) the proper Denjuu in (and threw a bunch of Pokemon into the mix) as well as renaming all of them. If this was say, making a list of all the Pokemon from Lei Dian Huang Bi Ka Qiu Chuan Shuo, that would be rather pointless as all of the Pokemon are in plus a few additions into the trivia. [[User:KingPepe2010|KingPepe2010]] ([[User talk:KingPepe2010|talk]]) 19:19, July 18, 2018 (UTC) |
||
| + | |||
| + | The list is not important. There is no need to specify which creatures are in the game and which are not. The list also unnecessarily makes the article too long. It can just be mentioned in the paragraph that some of the Denjuu were left out, and that the starter Pokemon (along with Poochyena, Zigzagoon, and their evolutions) from Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire are present. After all, the [[Pokemon Diamond and Jade]] article does not list all the new Denjuu names; it just says that the names were changed. |
||
Revision as of 20:06, 18 July 2018
Seeing how there was constant editing over the list itself beforehand, I might as well address it. Should the list of Denjuu/Pokemon stay or not? Please give reasons as to why it should stay or not. In the mean time, the article itself will remained locked until things get sorted out.
Personally, I think the list should stay as it documents all the Denjuu/Pokemon found within the game. It's obvious that Waixing was not faithful to the original source material and did not port all (to my knowledge) the proper Denjuu in (and threw a bunch of Pokemon into the mix) as well as renaming all of them. If this was say, making a list of all the Pokemon from Lei Dian Huang Bi Ka Qiu Chuan Shuo, that would be rather pointless as all of the Pokemon are in plus a few additions into the trivia. KingPepe2010 (talk) 19:19, July 18, 2018 (UTC)
The list is not important. There is no need to specify which creatures are in the game and which are not. The list also unnecessarily makes the article too long. It can just be mentioned in the paragraph that some of the Denjuu were left out, and that the starter Pokemon (along with Poochyena, Zigzagoon, and their evolutions) from Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire are present. After all, the Pokemon Diamond and Jade article does not list all the new Denjuu names; it just says that the names were changed.